Daily Archives: April 20, 2010

The Shakespeare authorship question isn’t settled — John Orloff Challenges Shapiro

It’s refreshing to see somebody taking on James Shapiro.  John Orloff, the screenwriter of “Anonymous,” does a commendable job of pointing out that Shapiro was extremely misleading (to say the least) in his description of the 1987 moot court involving three Supreme Court Justices.  If Shapiro can’t even be trusted to report accurately about what happened a mere 23 years ago, how can he be trusted to accurately report on events that occurred four centuries ago?  Here’s an excerpt from John Orloff’s opinion piece in the Los Angeles Times along with a link to the full article.  Three cheers for Orloff!   Matthew Cossolotto

The Shakespeare authorship question isn’t settled

And even if Shakespeare didn’t write all of the sonnets and plays attributed to him, the works’ centuries-old legacies would remain intact.

April 19, 2010|By John Orloff
As the screenwriter of “Anonymous,” the Roland Emmerich film about the Shakespeare authorship question now in production, I read with great interest James Shapiro’s April 11 Times Op-Ed article, “Alas, poor Shakespeare.”

I was particularly fascinated by Shapiro’s claim that U.S. Supreme Court Justices William J. Brennan Jr., Harry Blackmun and John Paul Stevens ruled “unanimously for Shakespeare and against the Earl of Oxford” in a 1987 moot court case.

Shapiro has, at best, oversimplified the facts.

In fact, Brennan, the senior justice on the case, did not rule on whether Shakespeare actually wrote the plays; he simply ruled that the Earl of Oxford did not meet the burden of proof required under the law.

Blackmun agreed, but then added, “That’s the legal answer. Whether it is the correct one causes me greater doubt” (emphasis mine).

Stevens went even further, saying: “I have lingering concerns. . . . You can’t help but have these gnawing doubts that this great author may perhaps have been someone else. . . . I would tend to draw the inference that the author of these plays was a nobleman. . . . There is a high probability that it was Edward de Vere [the Earl of Oxford].”

I would hardly characterize these as opinions “unanimously for Shakespeare and against the Earl of Oxford.”


May 1st Event in New York City — Charles Beauclerk Discusses His New Book: Shakespeare’s Lost Kingdom

Meet Charles Beauclerk (Earl of Burford), author of the new book Shakespeare’s Lost Kingdom, and descendent of Edward de Vere, who many believe to be the man who wrote under the pen-name of William Shakespeare. As special guest of Ron Song Destro and the Oxford Shakespeare Company, Mr. Beauclerk will give a presentation on the subject and sign books at 5:30 pm May 1st as part of the Tribeca Film and Family Festival celebration in Lower Manhattan at 74 Warren Street at the Church Street School for Music and Art, which houses the OSC theatre.

Shakespeare’s Lost Kingdom delves deep into the conflicts and personalities of Elizabethan England, as well as into the plays themselves to tell the true story of the “Soul of the Age.” To reserve a spot for this free event, please email Tickets@BoarMe.org. 

The Oxford Shakespeare Company plans to build a Globe theatre center in Lower Manhattan.

Contact:  Ron Song Destro
director, Oxford Shake-speare Co/BOAR
74 Warren St, NYC 10007
Tel 917-627-2334